Leadership in recruitment: how to identify this skill in a candidate?

Leadership is now a Soft Skill key for any company that wants to ensure its development, strengthen team cohesion and achieve its strategic goals. But how do you identify this quality when recruiting? What assessment tools and methods should be preferred? And above all, how to distinguish a genuine inspirational leader of a manager who only supervises?

In this article, we will explore effective leadership practices, tools for evaluating leadership, relevant questions to ask in interviews, and success indicators that measure its impact within an organization.

Why is leadership essential in business?

Leadership is not limited to a hierarchical function. It represents the ability to Guide, inspire and upholding employees to achieve a high level of performance. When exercised effectively, it contributes to improving the work climate, increasing employee satisfaction, increasing engagement and reducing turnover.

Strong leadership also stimulates collective performance, creates a shared vision and encourages innovation and adaptation to change. In times of crisis or organizational transformation, a solid leader acts as an anchor point for its teams.

With the evolution of working methods such as teleworking, hybrid management and the expectations of new generations, the role of the leader is changing. Today, he must be able to maintain team cohesion at a distance, promote transparent communication and cultivate a culture of trust. Modern leadership relies less on authority and more on the ability to create lasting commitment.

To learn more about this point, see our article on corporate culture and soft skills.

How do you assess a candidate's leadership skills?

The evaluation of a candidate's leadership must be rigorous. It consists in analyzing observable behaviors, concrete achievements and soft skills that make a difference.

Among the skills to be observed are the ability to communicate clearly, active listening, positive influence on team morale, self-awareness, openness to feedback, conflict management, the ability to make difficult decisions, but also the ability to motivate, innovate and find creative solutions.

Assessment methods include structured interviewing with behavioral questions to analyze reactions to past situations. Situations or business cases make it possible to observe how the candidate mobilizes his team around an objective. The 360 degree evaluation offers a complete vision thanks to the feedback of peers, managers and collaborators. Psychometric tests such as DISC or Hogan make it possible to understand the candidate's natural leadership style. Finally, internal surveys, as part of a promotion, measure the real perception of leadership among employees.

A common mistake is confusing charisma with real leadership. A candidate can have brilliant communication but fail to bring a team together in a sustainable way. It is therefore essential to base the assessment on observable evidence, for example lived situations where the candidate had to manage a crisis, motivate a team in decline in morale or lead a complex project.

It is precisely on this point that Yuzu brings added value. Thanks to its innovative approach togamified assessment, Yuzu makes it possible to recreate realistic professional situations in which candidates must make decisions and interact as they would at work. These scenarios reveal authentic behaviors and offer an accurate reading of leadership skills, such as the ability to manage a conflict, to mobilize a team, to give constructive feedback or to maintain a clear vision in the face of the unexpected. Recruiters then have objective and comparable data to identify candidates with the greatest leadership potential, beyond the impressions left during interviews.

What leadership practices are effective?

There are several leadership styles, each with strengths and limitations.

Transformational leadership is based on the ability to inspire, create a shared vision, and encourage innovation. Participatory leadership values the involvement of team members, promotes collective decision-making, and builds trust. Situational leadership adapts management style according to the needs of employees and their level of autonomy. Finally, leadership coaching supports employees in their professional development, with an approach based on listening and constructive feedback.

Effective leadership practices often rely on a combination of these styles. A successful leader knows when to encourage, when to delegate, when to reframe, and when to listen.

These practices are analyzed in more detail in our article on management styles that promote collective performance.

What tools are there to assess leadership?

The use of reliable assessment tools makes the analysis more objective.

The Leadership Circle Profile provides an in-depth analysis of underlying behaviors and beliefs. The 360 degree evaluation remains essential to measure the impact of the leader through multi-source feedback. Psychometric tests like the MBTI, DISC, or Hogan give information on dominant traits and behavioral preferences. Organizational climate surveys reveal how leadership style can help with team satisfaction and morale.

To go further, check out our guide on digital tools that optimize recruitment and skills assessment.

How to boost leadership in an organization?

Improving leadership is about more than choosing good managers. It is an ongoing process that requires long-term investment.

Key actions include the deployment of specific training programs for managers and future leaders, the use of individual coaching that develops self-awareness and emotional maturity, the promotion of a feedback culture where employees and managers regularly share their feedback, the creation of communities of practice where leaders discuss their challenges and find solutions together, and the regular analysis of HR indicators such as performance or organizational climate to adjust programs.

Businesses that succeed in developing leadership invest in a solid organizational system, where every manager has the tools and support they need to move forward.

What are the indicators of leadership success?

The success of a leader cannot be decreed, it can be measured.

The main indicators are employee satisfaction and their sense of recognition, the quality of the organizational climate that reflects trust and collaboration, the rate of engagement and retention of talent, the achievement of strategic goals and collective effectiveness, as well as the team's ability to manage change and maintain sustainable performance.

These aspects are explored in more detail in our article on The measurement of employee engagement.

What questions should you ask to assess a leader?

A well-conducted job interview can reveal real leadership skills.

Some effective questions to ask include: “Tell me about a situation where you had to manage a conflict in your team”, “How did you help an employee reach a difficult goal? ”, “What is your greatest achievement as a manager?” ”, “How do you react to negative feedback?” or “What strategy do you adopt to motivate a team in times of change?” ”.

These behavioral questions make it possible to verify whether the candidate really has the leadership skills sought.

Conclusion: towards sustainable and inspiring leadership

Identifying and evaluating the leadership of a candidate or an employee is a major strategic challenge for any organization. By combining relevant assessment methods, reliable tools, and indicators of success, businesses can identify and develop solid leaders who can guide their teams to collective success.

Effective leadership is not based solely on authority or hierarchy. It is embodied in the ability to inspire, mobilize sustainably and improve the work climate, guaranteeing long-term organizational success.

To go further, find out how improve your recruitment processes with Yuzu and select the leaders of tomorrow.

‍